I've had to edit several torrent titles while checking the torrent list, and that's by biggest pet peeve aside from 0 pics or worthless ones.
Some users put a description for the torrent title which is completely different than the file name or actual film name, or leave the title a mess (words jumbled together or misspelled).
A lot of users aren't following the description rules for Collections (adding a file list), so it doesn't seem too promising that we can get them to add better descriptions in general since apparently too many people don't read all the rules. Well, it would be an ongoing battle for a loooong time. Descriptions are nice, but they've never been a requirement here. I agree with others that it's not always possible to make good descriptions when you don't have details about the video which happens with a lot of clips. It can sometimes be difficult to make a good description in that case, unless you're a novelist or movie critic or something similar. The uploader might forget where he got it by the time he uploads it here also. And then there's foreign films. Take the Asian category for example. I remember spending a lot of time searching for a proper description for an Asian film someone else uploaded and never any description at all, so again the user might not always be able to provide a good description…unless they're willing and capable of writing their own synopsis or review.
I'm more concerned with proper titles and pics.
"What are your opinions on adding to the rules such requirements?"
We already basically have them. Torrent titles should at least state film name (studio isn't always possible, e.g. clips) or describe the video if the file name is numerical or random characters and the uploader doesn't have additional info. The title should match the file name if it's intelligible -no descriptions for the torrent title or other crap if the file name has the proper movie title. Pictures are already required and system enforced upon torrent uploading. Other users can upload pictures for bonus points and fix torrents with unacceptable pics if they're bothered or just want to help. Descriptions are optional and I'd leave them that way.
"What shall we do with torrents not fulfilling them?"
Try to get the user to fix it or fix it ourselves I suppose. I don't see a reason to remove or restrict them if the file itself is good and doesn't break rules. I guess we could maybe restrict repeat offenders who make crap torrent download pages and review the torrent first before letting it go live, tho I'd hesitate to do that when download pages are fixable.
"What do you think they should be, if you are for such requirements?"
See "What are your opinions on adding to the rules such requirements?"
@MikeChang:
All movies/clips should have at least 1 picture from the uploader, it's not difficult you just capture a screen shot while your watching the item in question.
I agree, tho there's people out there who don't know how to do a screenshot sadly. Ever see someone post a pic of their monitor screen in a thread -lol? I have. Oh well, we have a guide for that too. Pictures are already required and system enforced upon torrent uploads. AFAIK that bug still may exist where pics get deleted after upload (?), don't remember if it ever got fixed, but that and possibly Mods deleting unrelated pics is the reason for 0 pic download pages appearing on the torrent list. Sigh, some people even upload one of the torrent category icons for their 1 pic, or lovely landscape pics, or other random stuff.
@cannonmc:
My two cents worth is to have as few 'requirements' as possible.
I couldn't agree more!
I love Speedmaster8's global stencil suggestion minus requiring all fields be filled out for the upload button to be functional since descriptions are optional, and also it would slow the process. It'd be nice if QTM was updated too if this gets implemented.
Thinking about this more, and after reading Speedmaster8's post, I got an idea.
What if we let users upload descriptions for bonus points as with pictures???
Descriptions go to a queue to be reviewed by Mods. Users get points only if their description gets approved. Users who spam crap descriptions trying to get points get removed.
Speedmaster8's template can be incorporated in the description upload form too.
Users who intend to replace descriptions should c/p into their updated description whatever relevant portions the old description had.
Creating and enforcing tighter rules would hurt the torrent list more than it'd help IMO. Some people might upload less or take their torrents elsewhere, and users new to uploading might be even more put off. Torrent download pages can be fixed by us, and users can help too. The most important part is if the file itself is OK and is what's advertised on the 'tin'.
Edit: My, I'm terribly late. Threads such as these usually get posted in the Staff section…being rules and all. I missed this one because I didn't have time to read other parts of the forum lately.
It's great to have user feedback! ;D Where we can, we should make more threads public. Site improvement threads are my favorite.