@mhorndisk:
Wow this is really a bunch of "convincing talk," (explaining) which in determining when someone isn't being honest, goes on forever trying to "convince you that they're a good person," rather than just answering the simple matter at hand with simple deniability. I don't care about the fact that you think one politician did this and another did that, and therefore the whole mass of Republicans are racist. Hillary is still a racist, she came from Arkansas and praised Margaret Sanger, who said black people are weeds who need to be exterminated, and Trump is from NYC, where you don't get far by being a bigot. You can't say the whole Republican Establishment is racist because one Senator switched. That's a bunch of hullabaloo. The Democrats are still racist to this day, promising "free stuff," just like FDR did in the 30s to win the black vote. You say it had to do with something else, as in "philosophical reasons," but give ZERO examples, and therefore, I conclude what you are saying to be total nonsense. Thanks for trying!
(Only read the bold words if you don't feel like reading or can't understand the other parts)
I didn't deny it because I agree 100% with you that the Democratic Party was the party of the KKK historically. Some could and have argued that the Democratic Party indeed did create the KKK. I myself believe the Democratic Party created the KKK; hence, why I agree with you on that point. It is well documented that the Democrats worked with the KKK to disenfranchise black people and even killed black people and white people who tried to help black people. Where in my previous statement did I deny that fact? I literally began my post with "It is a well known fact that the Democratic Party created and supported the KKK for a time. No one has ever disputed that."
My statements weren't meant to be "convincing," I was simply stating the complex history behind the party realignments as they have been studied for decades by political and non-political scholars from many different angles. You cannot simplify something this complex effectively, but here are well-known facts that I'm sure you could easily check since there's so much info on Google about them (if you didn't learn them in school):
(1) Democrats did give the KKK a platform and are arguably the creators of the KKK.
(2) The KKK participated in voter suppression for a very long time with the help of the Democratic Party.
(3) Many, if not all, Southern segregationists were Democrats up until the Democratic Party began changing. After 1964 when the Civil Rights Act was passed, followed by the Voting Rights Act in 1965, most of those Southern segregationists abandoned the party. (I used Strom Thurmond as an example because he led the fillibuster against the Civil Rights Act that failed.)
(4) Following Nixon's infamous "Southern Strategy," all of those segregationists and racists who hadn't joined the Republican Party the way Strom Thurmond and others had done prior to the 1970s, joined the Republican Party. Robert Byrd remained in the Democratic Party due to West Virginia continuing to vote Democrat (they've always had a low population of people of color); therefore, he couldn't switch parties without risking the loss of his senate seat. He later claimed he'd "changed" his perception on people of color but who knows, we can't read minds ;D
(5) The Republican Party has constantly passed bills that courts have determined were crafted to disenfranchise black and brown people, and many of those bills were struck down after they were turned into laws. Republicans challenged the historic Voting Rights Act and were successful in dismantling one of its most effective provisions. The Democrats didn't do that, did they? Who is currently participating in voter suppression?
(6) David Duke was (maybe still is) a KKK member and he ran for office multiple times, including in the 2016 election, as a Republican, not a Democrat. I'm sure you can find current KKK members who are Democrats but you have to first find out (a) where that person lives because studies have shown local demographics play a huge role in whether white people prefer Democratic policies more than Republican policies and (b) whether that person realizes the Democratic Party of today is not the same Democratic Party that helped the KKK all those years ago.
Main Point
To say the Democratic and Republican Parties are the same now as they were prior to realignments is wholly ignorant to the very detailed history. Are you saying that President Lincoln, a Republican who represented the Union during the Civil War, was for the Confederacy? Because the Republican Party of today is the party that fights for the Confederate battle flag to be displayed on public statehouse grounds and want to preserve all of the Confederate monuments throughout the South. It was Jefferson Davis and the Democrats who represented the Confederacy, right? So if the parties never changed, why on earth is it the Republican Party fighting to preserve the battle flag of the Confederacy and not the Democrats who represented the Confederacy during the Civil War? Are you arguing that Abraham Lincoln was instead a Democrat since the Democrats are currently trying to remove the battle flag from statehouse grounds and other public property? You cannot pretend that the party realignments did not happen because they actually did happen. What you are arguing counters the documented history of our country.