Thank you for the clarification. I will go back to my bf and get the original store bought discs that are in the original DVD-9 format and will rip them to ISO in such a manner that they will retain their original DVD-9 format, as well as keep the non DVD (DVD-ROM) content contained within the original untouched ISO.
Given that there's a certain amount of question as to whether or not uploading a DVD-5 version when a DVD-9 version already exists would constitute a "duplicate", may I suggest a discussion among the staff to see if a mutual decision can be made collectively among the staff? My goal here is to be sure that everyone can be on the same page, and that the rules are made clear in order to be fair to everyone. While you are correct in that the size difference alone renders it another format, it stands to reason that it is in essence uploading another copy of a torrent that already exists, just in inferior quality by comparison.
Don't get me wrong though, I also would seem to think that uploading a DVD-5 when a DVD-9 does exist could constitute a duplicate, particularly seeing as how if you have a program such as DVD Shrink, you can render the DVD-5 version yourself. So all that being said, is this something you can bring to the staff for discussion for me please? I think it may help to clear a lot of potential headache in the future.
