I really enjoyed it in the beginning. The finale has changed my opinion of the show on a whole. For me it seemed like there was a great story being told that I was interested in finding it out where it was going but it ended with a great big sigh. That sigh translates into a saving it for the next season instead of just telling a complete story.
Watching the finale I came to the conclusion it's just watered down Battlestar Galactica without the Mormon ethos.