Was it wrong of me to ask about this? Im just curious thats all.
I'm not part of the site staff, just a long-time member. I do know that the site operators have norms and rules that they need to follow to keep the site out of hot water, and not all of those practices are published.
For example, several years ago the site had a link to a log of actions taken, regarding both torrents and users. I found this helpful, because if I saw an old, dead torrent that was deleted, and it was something that I thought more people would like, I would upload a new one. This log was taken off the site, and when I asked (in the forum) why, the answer from a site administrator was that it was "for secret reasons." Needless to say, I don't know the secret.
The operators of this site have a tough job and put in a lot of work, most of which we don't see. Sometimes things happen on here that are hard to understand, but it's their site and they get to make the rules.