@raphjd said in Simpsons recast another character:
Ah, so you are justifying.
Henry VIII never married a black woman, but that doesn't matter to the BBC.
Joan of Arc was a 17yo ginger white chick, but who cares about the truth on that?
Your BS justifications don't speak to the double standards I pointed out, by you liberals.
If you people demand that only fags can play fags, then you are being extreme hypocrites when you insist that gays playing heteros is ok. Likewise when you bitch about a woman playing a trans-man, but find no problem with a trans-man playing a woman.
Actually, what I'm justifying is that casting directors get to choose who plays what... and that's pretty much the end of it!
I've said before that "casting" is mostly exempt from most discrimination laws in the US. (Living near Disney in Florida, there are a TON of "equal opportunity" laws that they're exempt from because they consider ALL of their front-line "resort" employees to be "cast members")
My point isn't in support of or saying-against the re-casting of roles - either to more "realistic" representations (gays play gays), or against them (men play women).... (Ever seen the gay West Side Story - where Maria is Mario?). My point is that there is no government interference here... and there is no governmental interference even POSSIBLE (at least without changing a lot of laws!)
There are cultural forces at work here, not LEGAL ones... If the Simpsons wanted to ignore the Asians who objected to Apu, or the queers who object to Hank Azaria playing a gay character, they have been free to do so! But for the same reason that casting directors cast (sometimes MIScast) "stars" in certain roles, they also take into account what "extra exposure" can come from making (and changing) casting!
If you ask me, The Simpsons is likely making casting changes as-much to garner "fresh" publicity about the moves as for anything else! (Let's face it - these are just VOICES! The actual animation isn't changing at all!)
And you are a perfect example of their success in that!
Finally, for what its worth: Saint Joan of Arc was about 5 feet 2β3 inches tall, was athletic, had dark brown hair and a somewhat short neck. 