@urx585:
Here is an abstract from an article in an English-language academic journal that affirms the queerness of THE UMBRELLAS OF CHERBOURG: https://muse.jhu.edu/article/590952/summary
There are many others, but you have to search for French-language articles.
That is just an excerpt of a review of a book, but it doesn't indicate that the book affirms the film's "queerness" at all. Instead, it states that the book is focused on comparing aspects of Demy's films to aspects of fairy tales. I read elsewhere that one film (Donkey Skin) is analyzed through the lens of "gay aesthetics" in the book.
More importantly, it doesn't hint at any element of the film that would constitute gay cultural aspects, subtext, etc. that are particularly discernible to the French and which would indicate a need to give more weight to the opinion of French GTRU users in determining whether the torrent should be allowed or not. The author of the book that is reviewed in that article is not even French, but American.
Here's a doctoral thesis entitled "Queer Enchantments" that looks at Demy's films through "a variety of queer and feminist lenses". It even has a 25 page section on Umbrellas but does not once in the entire thesis mention anything queer about it and even describes it as an "idealised heterosexual love story".
http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/107760/1/WRAP_Theses_Mulligan_2017.pdf
Your comments are very sensible and I don't disagree with you. I just ask: what's the harm in having it available here, too? It's gay enough. There are other torrent sites for movies but why send people elsewhere?
I already said I don't think it's important to have it here but I would also agree that it's not particularly harmful to have it here, either. It's simply a matter of convenience for some users for a film like this.
In a discussion a while back on this site regarding non-porn films, I asked the question, "Where do you draw the line?" I feel comfortable drawing it to exclude both The Lighthouse and The Umbrellas of Cherbourg but of course others can disagree and it doesn't bother me one way or the other what is decided. Even being familiar with them, it would never have occurred to me to look for either of them here on a gay torrent site if I wanted to watch them again, except for this discussion.
However, I really do appreciate being able to find gay-themed films here, many of which are difficult or impossible to find elsewhere, and I think that is important.
In the end, it's a privately-owned torrent site and the owner can do what he pleases with no obligation to explain or justify his actions.