Cut them down to within a millimeter of the overhang and then use an emery board/buffer to comfortably buff them down to the skin (use back-lighting to better see where the skin ends).
If all else fails, you can always grab a box of "Finger Cots" at the drug store. You can even carry a couple in a small plastic baggie in your wallet in case a fingering opportunity comes up (OR in case you need to serve as an impromptu drug mule when returning from one of your frequent trips to Colombia).
Just be sure not to leave them loose in your wallet, lest they randomly fall out at an inconvenient time, leading people around you to think they're "tiny condoms" for your 2-inch dick. It'll be like the inverse of that time when Zac Efron "accidentally" dropped that Magnum condom from his pocket on the red carpet: