Well, I am talking about the initial seeding only.
To illustrate my case see pic 1.
I have not even finished the upload and Mike 2009 (who is blessed with a fast line) already has pumped out 3.5Gb, giving him a ratio of over 5.0 on that file.
Pic 2 shows the stats after the upload is complete.
I have seeded the file and my upload ratio of course improved by 1.14 GB.
But that's nothing compared to Mike2099, who by now has uploaded 6.5 GB and has a ratio of over 7.0 on this file. Of course he's now there preferred seeder and I can drop out because I can't compete with this.
I don't know if Mike2009 is also actively participating by sharing his collection or if he's just leeching. He's just an example to illustrate my concern and it's in no way meant that he's not also sharing new material.
My only point is that people with fast lines NEVER have to worry about their ratios. They always have a ratio which allows them to download whatever they want without the need to also upload new material. I, and many others, HAVE TO provide new content all the time (for the benefit of ALL users) to keep a positive ratio.
Therefore my plea: reward people who provide new content because they invest a lot of time and work and help them achieving a better ratio. One possibility would be to double the uploaded data amount. E.g. in this case where I seeded a 1GB movie to give a 1GB credit towards the new material.
Such a solution would help me and others a lot and give us some breathing room. As much as I would love to download the occasional DVD-R… I can't do it because it would hit my ratio really hard.
B.

