@raphjd:
As far as I'm concerned, it crosses the line of basic common decency, which is why we banned it in the first place.
the 'line of basic common decency' is a subjective assessment, which probably wouldn't include scat, rosebuds, bdsm and many other activities either, in some people's opinions.
it shouldn't be up to staff to impose their tastes on the rules in an attempt to protect members' sensitivities (hence the poll, I guess, so thanks for asking )
as long as such activity is clearly signposted in the torrent's description, and is between consenting adults, then it is up to the individual member whether they download it or not.
caveat emptor