Pardon me if it is too personal of a question, but if it is mimicking you're after, it may help here if you could tell what dildo size you're usually using for that. There are several dildo show enthusiasts, Pup Davey, for example, but the size of dildos he uses is for experienced anal players, I'd say. Would you be interested in mimicking something like that, or are you into something less massive?
https://www.gaytorrent.ru/details.php?id=5e7d80359794c2082dd2e93f5781fde2d8242c070d9ad4b3