Saw this thread and couldn't resist.
My hands down pick would be: York Powers. I loved how masculine and vocal he was. I download ANYTHING if I see his name in the cast list.
There are so many others, but these are the ones I go back to often:
Mark Anthony - Stunning. His scene in The Anchor Hotel is a favorite.
Eric Carter - He mainly did movies with Robert Prion. His eyes were stunning.
Bobby Cordova - A Latin model who did some good solo work. Good bubble butt.
Ion Davidov - Always liked his look.
Johnny Harden - He mostly did solos, but man, were they good!
Scott Hardman - Always loved his masculinity. He has a big butt, too.
Tyler Hart - A cute blonde with a really good bubble butt.
Josh Harting - He had one of the best bubble butts.
Hawkeye - A Defiant Productions model. Always thought he had pretty eyes.
Ryan Idol - Loved his bubble butt. I have a friend who just happened to meet him in a bar. He just happened to know the person Ryan was with. My friend described him as, "Dumb as a bucket of rocks."
Jason McCain - He didn't have the best body [and mostly did straight movies], but what made him hotter to me was knowing he did mostly straight movies before doing a few gay movies.
Kevin Miles - Another good bubble butt.
Todd Mitchell - Always loved his eyes.
Tristan - Another Defiant Productions favorite. His cumshots are/were incredible.
Zach Richards/Ash McKay - Always thought he was sort of an American version of Lukas Ridgeston. Not as handsome, but a good runner-up.
Lukas Ridgeston - Who wouldn't want him?
Mike Roberts - Always thought he had beautiful eyes, even though he was allegedly gay for pay)
Hal Rockland - always thought he was the best looking of the three brothers)
Dredd Scott - Loved his masculinity and tattoos.
Dean Spencer
Les Stine - Not the best looking guy, but his scenes were always engaging, and I always liked how hairy he was.
Troy Timmons - A CitiBoyz model. Not the hottest, but he filmed one of the best self-suck videos of all time
Rick Waters - A Defiant Productions model. Not the hottest guy per se, but there was always something about him that I liked; it's probably his bubble butt
Brandon Weber/Sebastian Madrid - Always liked his look. His scene with Kyle Kennedy in Lured to Costa Rica is a favorite.
Jeff White - always had a thing for blondes and he was one of the best. Loved his bubble butt.
Christian Wilde - Liked him the second I saw him.