I forgot to add to the list Armond Rizzo (not phimotic, but his skin is up most of the time). Also, I recently discovered two other guys with tight foreskins. One is a british twink called Chad Chambers, and the other is a cute latino guy called Trelino. Unfortunately all of them are bottoms and in most of their videos their cocks don't even get sucked even for a second, but in those few vids where it happens it's HAWTTTTT.
I also discovered two MilitaryClassified . com BJ vids with phimotic guys, one is with a guy called Cole, and one with Aden.
Oh, and how could I forget Rico from All Australian Boys and Mitchel Knight from SuckOffGuys.
Other suggestions would be much appreciated.